METHODS
Ninety patients diagnosed with EC were analyzed. Fifty-four patients were at Stage I (60%), 19 were at
Stage II (21%) and 17 (19%) were at Stage III. Fifty-four patients (60%) had grades on pre-operative
biopsies, 31 patients (34%) had grades on frozen sections and 88 patients (98%) had grades on postoperative
specimens. Depth of myometrial invasion was reported in 54 patients (60%) based on frozen
sections and in all patients on post-operative specimens. Eight patients (9%) underwent no lymphadenectomy,
32 patients (36%) underwent pelvic lymphadenectomy and 50 patients (55%) underwent
pelvic and para-aortic lymphadenectomy.
RESULTS
There were five patients for whom tumors were up-graded when pre-operative biopsies and frozen sections
were. There were 17 patients for whom tumors were up-graded and four patients for whom tumors
were down-graded when pre-operative biopsies and post-operative specimens were compared. There
were six patients for whom tumors were up-graded when frozen sections and post-operative specimens
were compared and the distribution of patients between intra-operatively and post-operatively assigned
tumor grade groups was statistically significant.
CONCLUSION
For surgeons who do not perform complete surgical staging for every patient with EC, clinical judgment
should only be efficient when augmented with information obtained from frozen sections.
Keywords: Adjuvant; endometrial neoplasms; frozen sections; hysterectomy; lymph node excision; radiotherapy
Among prognostic features for ECs, depth of myometrial
invasion is particularly associated with pelvic
lymph node involvement and parametrium extension,
which may alter both staging and therapeutic approaches.
The assessment of the depth of myometrial
invasion will allow an adequate selection of low-risk
cases and avoid unnecessary lymphadenectomy and
associated morbidity.[
The aim of this study was to evaluate the compatibility
of tumor grades in pre-operative biopsies, frozen
sections, and post-operative specimens and to evaluate
the adequacy of a selective surgical staging policy
based on information obtained from frozen sections to
avoid lymphadenectomy in patients with EC who were
admitted for post-operative adjuvant radiotherapy.
A three-tiered grading system (as suggested by FIGO) was used to evaluate tumor grade. The depth of myometrial invasion was recorded in millimeters and grouped as <50% invasion or >50% invasion. Lymphovascular space invasion was defined when malignant cells were present in the endothelial-lined spaces. Tumor size was measured in centimeters in its maximum extension. Tumor location was defined as either involving one subsite or diffusely involving the uterine cavity.
Patient and Tumor Characteristics
Median age was 64 years (30-81 years). Fifty-four patients
(60%) were at Stage I (22 in Stage Ia and 32 in
Stage Ib), 19 patients (21%) were at Stage II, and 17
patients (19%) were at Stage III (six in Stage IIIa, seven
in Stage IIIc1, and four in Stage IIIc2). The distribution
of patients according to stage is shown in Table
Fifty-four patients (60%) had tumor grades assigned
on pre-operative biopsies. Of these, 25 had
Grade 1 tumors (46%), 22 had Grade 2 tumors (41%),
and seven had Grade 3 tumors (13%). Thirty-one patients
(34%) had tumor grades assigned on frozen sections.
Of these, 13 had Grade 1 tumors (42%), 13 had
Grade 2 tumors (42%), and five had Grade 3 tumors
(16%). Eighty-eight patients (98%) had tumor grades
assigned on post-operative specimens. Of these, 18 had
Grade 1 tumors (20%), 52 had Grade 2 tumors (60%),
and 18 had Grade 3 tumors (20%). Tumor grades by
method of assignment are shown in Table
Depth of myometrial invasion was reported in 54 patients (60%) based on frozen sections. Of these, 28 had <50% invasion (52%) and 26 had greater than 50% invasion (48%). Depth of myometrial invasion was reported in all patients on post-operative specimens. Of these, 35 had <50% invasion (39%) and 55 had >50% invasion (61%). On post-operative specimens, tumor size ranged from 1 to 10 cm (median, 5 cm). Tumors were localized in only one subsite in the uterine cavity in 38 patients (42%) and diffusely involved the uterine cavity in 52 (58%).
Surgery
Of all patients, 8 (9%) underwent TAH and BSO without
lymphadenectomy whereas 32 (36%) underwent pelvic
lymphadenectomy in addition to TAH and BSO and 50
(55%) underwent pelvic and para-aortic lymphadenectomy
and peritoneal washing in addition to TAH and
BSO. Of eight patients who underwent TAH and BSO
without lymphadenectomy, seven were at Stage I and
the remaining one was at Stage II. Of 17 patients with
Stage III disease, 14 underwent pelvic and para-aortic
lymphadenectomy and peritoneal washing in addition
to TAH and BSO and three underwent pelvic lymphadenectomy
in addition to TAH and BSO. For 32
patients who underwent only pelvic lymphadenectomy,
the number of dissected pelvic lymph nodes ranged
from 3 to 47 (median, 17). For 50 patients who underwent
pelvic and para-aortic lymphadenectomy, the
number of dissected pelvic lymph nodes ranged from
5 to 44 (median, 21) and the number of dissected paraaortic
lymph nodes ranged from 1 to 51 (median, 7).
Radiotherapy
Statistical Analysis
External beam pelvic radiotherapy was given at a dose of
50.4 Gy in 1.8 Gy fractions in 24 patients (27%), 45 Gy in
1.8 Gy fractions in 64 patients (71%), and 46 Gy in 2 Gy
fractions in 2 patients (2%). Median total dose of radiotherapy
was 45 Gy and median fraction size was 1.8 Gy.
Following external beam pelvic radiotherapy, an HDR
brachytherapy boost to the vaginal cuff was applied to
69 (77%), patients at a fraction dose of 5-7 Gy (median,
6 Gy) in 2-4 fractions (median, three fractions). Organs
at risk dose constraints were calculated using total equieffective
dose (EQD2) according to GEC-ESTRO recommendations.[
Patient characteristics were compared with a Chi-square
test. Histological grade (Grade 1 vs. Grade 2 and Grade 3) and depth of myometrial invasion were used as categorical
variables. Survival analysis was performed using
the method of Kaplan and Meier method. Overall survival
and disease-free survival were calculated starting
from the date of the biopsy. Statistical analysis was carried
out using the SPSS 21.0 software package. P ≤0.05
was used as the statistical significance level.
There were 54 patients for whom depth of myometrial invasion was assigned both intraoperatively and postoperatively. Depth of invasion was upgraded for six of these patients and downgraded for none. The distribution of patients between intraoperatively and postoperatively assigned depth of myometrial invasion groups was statistically significant (p<0.001, χ2=34.47). Information on lymphovascular space invasion was available on post-operative specimens in 75 patients (83%). Of these patients, lymphovascular space invasion was reported in 21 (28%).
Recurrences were observed in eight patients: At
para-aortic lymph nodes in one, as liver metastases in
one, as abdominal implants in one, and as pulmonary
metastases in five. The patient presenting with a recurrence
at para-aortic lymph nodes was initially treated
with TAH and BSO without lymphadenectomy due
to the absence of a tumor grade on frozen section. Of
recurrent patients, five died of their disease at 3-41 months (median, 17 months). The remaining three patients
were alive with disease at 34-91 months (median,
67 months) following treatment with palliative chemotherapy.
Five patients died due to causes not related to
their disease at 14-77 months (median, 67 months). At
a mean follow-up of 44 months (ranging from 3 months
to 104 months), overall survival at 1 year, 3 years, and
5 years was 98±2% (n=80), 92±3% (n=47), and 90±4%
(n=29), respectively, and disease-free survival at 1 year,
3 years, and 5 years was 98±2% (n=80), 90±4% (n=45),
and 88±4% (n=27), respectively (Fig.
The primary aim of this study was to evaluate the compatibility of tumor grades in various specimens. However, not all patients in the study had tumor grades assigned on more than 1 specimen. Tumor grades were reported in pre-operative biopsies in 60%, frozen sections in 34%, and post-operative specimens in 98% of patients. To obtain comparable data, those patients having reports on at least two separate occasions were selected for analysis. When tumor grades on pre-operative biopsies and frozen sections were compared, tumors were upgraded in 26% of patients. Similarly, when tumor grades on pre-operative biopsies and post-operative specimens were compared, tumors were upgraded in 33% of patients. On the contrary, when tumor grades on frozen sections and post-operative specimens were compared, tumors were upgraded in only 19% of patients.
In a retrospective study evaluating tumor grade
concordance in 118 patients, frozen sections and postoperative
specimens were in agreement in 56% and tumors
were upgraded in 44% of 73 patients with Grade
I tumors in post-operative specimens, whereas frozen
sections and post-operative specimens were in agreement
in 80% and tumors were upgraded in 13% and
downgraded in 7% in 45 patients with Grade 2 tumors
in post-operative specimens. Overall, the concordance
in terms of tumor grade between frozen sections and
post-operative specimens was 65%.[12] In a study by
Batista et al.[
In a retrospective analysis, the accuracy of frozen
sections in determining the depth of myometrial invasion
was reported to be high. The concordance between
frozen sections and post-operative specimens
amounted to 93% for all patients and the accuracy
of the frozen sections was not influenced by overall
stage. Sensitivity and specificity for all patients were
98% and 89%, respectively.[
The secondary aim of this study was to evaluate
the adequacy of frozen sections in attempt to avoid
lymphadenectomy in patients with EC. Along with
other pathological features such as the depth of myometrial
invasion, cervical stromal involvement, and lymphovascular space invasion, tumor grade impacts
the likelihood of nodal spread and disease recurrence.
[
Helpman et al.[
Most management guidelines recommend TAH
and BSO without lymphadenectomy (only if complemented
with intraoperative assessment of the surgical
specimen) for patients who have been diagnosed with
Grade 1 and Grade 2 tumors based on their pre-operative
biopsies, whereas pelvic (and para-aortic) lymph
node dissection remains as the staging procedure of
choice for all of the remaining patients. Of eight patients
who underwent TAH and BSO without lymphadenectomy
in this study, only one was at Stage II
(hence receiving the less than adequate surgical procedure).
However, if the information available through
intraoperative specimens had been disregarded, the
margin of error in terms of the adequacy of the surgical
procedure would have been 40% based on the
comparison of tumor grades on pre-operative biopsies
and post-operative specimens. These findings suggest
that for surgeons who do not perform complete surgical
staging for every patient with EC, clinical judgment
should only be efficient when augmented with information
obtained from frozen sections.
Peer-review: Externally peer-reviewed.
Conflict of Interest: All authors declared no conflict of interest.
Ethics Committee Approval: The study was approved by
the Sakarya University Faculty of Medicine Non-interventional
Ethics Committee (No: 71522473/050.01.04/592,
Date: 01/12/2020).
Financial Support: None declared.
Authorship contributions: Concept - H.Ş.E., H.H.; Design
- H.Ş.E., H.H.; Supervision - H.Ş.E.; Funding - None;
Materials - H.H., Ö.Y.; Data collection and/or processing
- H.H., Ö.Y.; Data analysis and/or interpretation - H.Ş.E.,
H.H.; Literature search - H.H., Ö.Y.; Writing - H.H., Ö.Y.;
Critical review - H.Ş.E.